Is it ethical for an engineer to work for a local government agency and for a consulting firm that deals with this agency?
O'Malley, a professional engineer who works for a design consulting firm, is also retained by a municipality to furnish advice, perform studies, and review requests for proposals (RFPs). Under the terms of the agreement with the Municipality, O'Malley is barred from preparing the plans for any private client of the consulting firm, if those plans will eventually be submitted to the Municipality for review or approval. O'Malley has a similar agreement with the consulting firm. However, other people working for the design consulting firm can help clients prepare plans to submit to the Municipality.
Are the arrangements described above sufficient to prevent a conflict of interest? Would having additional information change your assessment of the situation? If so, what information? How would it be useful?
Suppose Engineers O'Connor and O'Brien of the design consulting firm are preparing plans for a client which will be submitted to the municipality. O'Connor and O'Brien are confronted with a problem in preparing those plans that O'Malley has the expertise to answer. O'Connor and O'Brien approach O'Malley with the problem and ask for his advice.
What should O'Malley do? Are the arrangements described above sufficient to provide O'Malley with the proper guidance?
--adapted from NSPE Case No. 90-7
NSPE Code of Ethics An earlier version may have been used in this case.
Return to Professional Ethics in Engineering Practice: Discussion Cases Based on NSPE BER Cases
This ethical decision-making framework developed by Dr. Michael Davis of the Illinois Institute of Technology is useful in guiding discussions around case studies and other ethics courses and workshop activities.
This bibliography includes examples of different ways instructors have used case studies to introduce ethical topics to their students and resources for finding cases and incorporating them into the classroom.
In this essay, Dr. Whitbeck outlines an 'agent-centered' approach to learning ethics. The central aim is to prepare students to act wisely and responsibly when faced with moral problems. She provides a number of examples and cases with descriptions of questions and directions for promoting student participation and stimulating thought and discussion.