Author / Contributor
image for Hiroshi Iino
Hiroshi Iino More Posts
Parent Resource188
Three Teaching Case Studies of Accidents in Nuclear Energy Development in Japan

Added08/15/2006

Updated01/29/2016

Author(s) Hiroshi Iino

Author: Hiroshi Iino

Kanazawa Institute of Technology, Japan

Author: Hiroshi Iino

Kanazawa Institute of Technology, Japan

Read More
Share with EEL Yes
Rights For more information on permissions to use this material please see: http://onlineethics.org/permissions.aspx
Year 2006
Publisher provided Keywords Case Cases chemical Corporate design Discipline: ENGINEERING Essay ethics Government Historical Nuclear professional PUBLIC radioactive RESPONSIBILITY safety Setting: substances teaching Type: University worker
Publisher National Academy of Engineering
Language English

Search this Publication

Case 3: Criticality Accident at JCO in 1999

(4) In 1999, a criticality accident at JCO, a subsidiary of Sumitomo Metal Mining Co., astonished the Japanese people and the world at large. Three workers were refining an enriched (the uranium235 concentration was 18.8%) uranyl nitrate solution for a research fast breeder reactor in Tokaimura, the same village of the second accident. They were pouring uranyl nitrate solution from a five-liter stainless beaker through a funnel into the sedimentation tank that was installed there (but used for other purpose). When they poured the fourteenth dose, they saw a blue flash. The total amount of uranium poured was 16.8 kg, seven times larger than the maximum allowable quantity for the tank. In order to save time, they had changed the process on their own and violated a legal requirement in the operation manuals, which the company had established a few years before. Three were immediately hospitalized and two later died because of excessive neutron and gamma ray exposure. The plant equipment had been designed with a critically safe slim geometry such as 117mm in diameter and 3500 mm high (80 liters in volume), which also prohibited efficient operation. But the roughly spherical sedimentation tank (450mm in diameter, 600mm high and 100 liters in volume) was an exception. This was an "irradiation" accident, not a "contamination" accident. One hundred and fifty other persons received a radiation exposure, but it was less than a maximum allowable annual dose.

Three kinds of the operation are shown in Fig. 5. This was a special operation for them and, therefore, required some special care. But no qualified engineers were in charge of the operation and workers were not educated well for the operation and accompanying risks partly because the company was in a difficult financial position, which could not be a reason of the excuse. This is simply a problem of poor management and management ethics.

This accident teaches students following lessons:

  1. Poor management. Managements illegally changed the operation manuals and they neither allocated qualified engineers nor educated workers for the operation.
  2. The management of the operation was so badly controlled that the workers tried to improve efficiency without knowledge and approval of qualified engineers. Trust and good communication between engineers and workers are essential for safety of any operation.
  3. Even under such a situation, engineers who were not in charge of the operation could have pointed out the danger to the management, when they found them.

Several managers (ex-engineers) including the plant manager were put on trial and JCO closed all the operation due to this accident.

For a final report on the accident in Japanese, refer to "Report from Investigation Committee for Criticality Accident in Uranium Treating Plant" December 24, 1999, pp.1-141

Return to Three Teaching Case Studies of Accidents in Nuclear Energy Development in Japan

Author: Hiroshi Iino

  • Using Case Studies Bibliography

    Added03/26/2010

    Updated09/02/2016

    This bibliography includes examples of different ways instructors have used case studies to introduce ethical topics to their students and resources for finding cases and incorporating them into the classroom.

    Author(s) Kelly Laas
    Year 2016
  • Added06/26/2006

    Updated06/07/2016

    In this essay, Dr. Whitbeck outlines an 'agent-centered' approach to learning ethics. The central aim is to prepare students to act wisely and responsibly when faced with moral problems. She provides a number of examples and cases with descriptions of questions and directions for promoting student participation and stimulating thought and discussion.

    Year 1995
Cite this page: "Case 3: Criticality Accident at JCO in 1999" Online Ethics Center for Engineering 12/18/2009 OEC Accessed: Monday, May 20, 2019 <www.onlineethics.org/Resources/japancases/22352.aspx>